Best Answer
madazv8
,
26 May 2023 - 03:25 PM
So an update on this saga. Car is running much better, but I would say still not perfect as reasons below...
After doing everything I could and still not getting to the bottom of this issue, I finally folded and admitted defeat and took the car to the mini specialist. This was after replacing the MAP sensor I wasted as per above and on my other thread about replacing it. It has been an interesting journey of learning and a few times could have led me down some crazy dead ends.
In summary, the car would not idle well. It was clear visually that it was throwing excessive fuel down the intake at idle. Lambda was reading constant high, never went closed loop, and as a result it would only run in limp mode with bugger all power.
So. A day after dropping the car off I get a TXT message with good news. Car is running better.
A spare ECU was plugged in, no change. ECU ruled out.
Confirmed no vacuum leaks. I had gone over this countless times, and was confident that was the case.
Checked fuel pressure. Spot on.
Measured valve lift with a dial gauge. Seems somebody has fitted a high lift CAM ! We know the SPI doesn't like that ! and most likely why I have high MAP reading.
Un-plugged the coolant temp sensor and connected an original Rover item which he had on the shelf.
Place said coolant sensor in a mug of boiled water - immediate difference ! Car idles.
Frustratingly I had ruled out the coolant sensor as it was new, and it also seemed to be working according to MEMS apps. The mechanic has had experience with recent replacement coolant sensors being bad. Even though the readings on the MEMS apps seemed to look realistic, somehow it does not marry up to the ECU. My MAP reading is still too high, and the car bogs a bit at mid range under hard throttle, but that is because of this camshaft. I'll live with that for now.
So lessons learned:
When everything you read says the coolant temp sensor has the biggest effect. Challenge your assumption that yours is ok. Especially if it is a replacement.
The Vacuum gauge diagnosis I talked about earlier in this thread could have had me looking at CAM timing and valve guides etc. These are written for carby engines. Beware.
Don't pull stupid amount of vacuum on your MAP sensor, expensive mistake.
Anyway, It has been an education. Thanks to all who took the time to offer wisdom. I'm off for a 500km drive this weekend :)
Go to the full post