I remember seeing the bini badge on one of the magazine feature car i think. It really suited the clean style the owner was going for. Old badges have a bit too much detail and is a very dated design.
Do what you want, don't let people with their own prejudices sway you from carrying out your own ideas.
This... the new badge design is about the nicest part of the new MINIs. I'm tempted to put one on the front of my mini, just double sided taped on so can be removed if I cahnge my mind.